Intellectual Inertia of the Indian Intelligentsia
December 10th, 2006
The fact of the matter is that television and movies today constitute a herculean chunk of the artistic facade of any society. Their immense reach far outweighs any other vehicle of cultural expression. Therefore, their content can safely be taken to principally represent the creative quotient of the entire society in general. If this is the case, I am afraid to say, but the country has seldom found itself so devoid of originality of ideas, and the will of creation.
Whereas on one hand the small screen is content at providing airtime to the convoluted, disfigured fantasies of the likes of Ekta kapoor, the silver screen meekly bends down to the whims and fancies of cry-baby directors like Karan Johar and Chopra family. Whereas the small screen blatantly copies every american success story (yes, KBC, Indian laughter challenge and all those reality competitions are shameless copies), imagination and creativity seem to be giving way to obscene vulgarity and violence on the big screen. I am not saying that vulgarity and violence should be wholly abhorred. I am just saying that they should not act as veils to hide the sheer ineptitude of directors at using whatever little grey matter they have been blessed with. I fondly remember the days when a Sunday morning on Doordarshan used to be a worthwhile waiting experience. And I miss the brilliance of a Hrishikesh Mukherjee at weaving a complex interplay of human emotions.
I hardly hate anything more than creations which have to take the support of cheap populist gimmicks to get accepted by the society. Art is a sacred profession. It is so much more personal than technology. Its creation should not be governed by something as vulgar as societal acceptance and money. Sadly, this is what seems to be happening to the entertainment industry in India. Movies and serials try to play into the hands of the college going, big city student populace most of whom think that their last breakup was the worst thing to have hit the society in the last 50 years and who are blessed with stupid enough parents with deep enough pockets to have any kind of discriminatory power anyways. Or they go to the other extreme and try to gain the acceptance of those over-the-middle age parents, who somehow have forgotten what good entertainment used to taste like and have now become numb enough not to raise an eyebrow when an Ekta Kapoor sends any army of intermarried, conniving, glossy and fake actors to throw them into what can only be described as a state of mental anesthesia.
Hats off to those who claim to be the spearheads of Indian imagination. I can only imagine, if the bayonet is so blunt, how ineffective the rifle has become.
Superb expressions; those TV serials probably don't deserve to be described in such creatively written articles.
I don't blame Ekta Kapoor or Johar for this state of affair. They are businessmen and selling what sells, and I appreciate them for figuring out how to make money in a industry where most people lose. Problem is - people watch and like that crap! I'm sure Kapoor and Johar will make, or will be forced to make, good movies and serials (they may need some help though!) if those were to sell more than *K*KKG and *K*Kusum.
Truly agree with Nitin here.
Dreammakers sell what dreams that we want to see. And its a sad state that almost all serials/actors/concepts look the same in every channel...
There was a time when we had some really good serials of content..
Buniyaad, Rajni, Udaan, Mungerilal ke haseen sapne, Yeh jo hain zindagi, Kashish, Kathasagar....
We seem to have just got stuck in a time warp and just may be we can come out of it before it becomes too late...
I don't blame Ekta Kapoor and Johar either. Atleast not for the state of affairs. They are just a reflection of our society in general. But I do blame their ethics. I do blame them for selling what they consider art on materialistic terms. The only way I can explain this is that they value money more than what they are doing. Read this speech. I just love it :
http://home3.inet.tele.dk/stadil/spe_kc.htm
And as far as people like kapoor and johar producing what society likes is concerned, I am sceptical that even if somehow society grows wise and starts liking intelligent material, these people would find it impossible to deliver the goods. I feel that they lack the creativity and originality to produce a beautiful and entertaining work of art. They are what you call scum. Ironical but the most mindless guys get to make the most important decisions, similar to politics in India 🙂
Nukkad, Kakkaji kahin, Mr. Yogi, Discovery of India, Jungle book, Shriman Shrimati, Eureka, Surabhi... list is endless 🙂